Saturday, September 19, 2009

Defending Steinbeck's Sensationalism

I was surprised at first to find out that most of the criticism aimed at The Grapes of Wrath came not from the greedy machines of banks and other profit-obsessed entities that are so lambasted in the novel, but rather from the migrant workers themselves, the protagonists of Steinbeck’s story. I then realized that people rarely like to see themselves as they really are, and they are overly critical of themselves, even when there is little to rightly criticize. When they see a photograph of themselves or look in the mirror, the first thing people tend to notice are their flaws. Despite this, they’re also quick to get defensive.

Though I’m perfectly prepared to get some flack for this comparison, I keep thinking of Sophie from Music and Lyrics, and how she lets her entire life be negatively affected by a fictionalized account of herself that isn’t exactly hunky-dory. She tries her best to prove that she is not the melodramatic, manipulative main character nestled in the pages of the nation’s latest bestseller – which turns into a self-fulfilling prophecy, as Hugh Grant’s character points out in his only display of competence in the movie. She becomes so obsessed with fighting an image of herself that she doesn’t like that the image ends up suiting her all the better.

The same is probably true for Grapes. The Okies were able to see themselves from a different perspective for once, and while the image portrayed is not necessarily a bad one, it does highlight a few flaws that I myself would probably want to cover up were I the subject: stubbornness, foolishness, perhaps a little hypocrisy, and, of course, extreme poverty. As I mentioned in class, the migrant mother in Dorothea Lange’s famous Depression-era photograph claimed that the widely published portrait only made her and her family feel ashamed of their destitution. They felt they were being judged. And even though artists like Lange and Steinbeck may have raised general awareness of the situation of Dust Bowl refugees, few families found direct assistance; most felt they were only being used.

There’s also the question of whether Steinbeck was truthful. Though some families’ experiences were similar to or perhaps even worse than those of the Joads or the Wilsons, I doubt that all of them met such hardships. But what good is a book that expounds upon a family’s virtually hiccup-free journey to California? Uncle Tom’s Cabin and Silent Spring, as was mentioned in class, likewise overexaggerated the situations they were attempting to alter. Their authors wanted to shock, to get a reaction – how else can change be wrought? Steinbeck makes you feel for the Joads by making them human – by giving them flaws – and then takes you on such an emotional journey that by the end of it you’re downright angry at what they’ve had to go through. The book was intended, I think, for a middle- and upper-class populace that had little knowledge and even less sympathy for the lives of Okies and Arkies. Naturally it would be of little interest and perhaps some offence to the people living those lives, who could do nothing to help their own situation.

Don´t kill the turtle

In chapter three, Steinbeck describes the movement of the turtle. The turtle slowly progresses along dragging his shell. He approaches the embankment of the road and moseys on up. ¨As the embankment grew steeper and steeper, the more frantic were the efforts of the land turtle¨ (p. 21.) Like the Okies, the turtle is determined and consistent in his motion.

At the end of this chapter, Steinbeck describes the near death experience of the turtle. In the first instance, ¨a sedan driven by a forty-year old woman¨ approaches and swerves away from the turtle as to not hit him. Shortly after, a truck advances and intentionally swerves to hit the turtle.

I found it interesting that Steinbeck chose to describe the driver of the first car and leaves the second car anonymous. He allows us to imagine the forty-year old woman in her car making the conscious decision to avoid killing the turtle. While, in the case of the truck it is the reverse, we are left with no image of the driver. The truck is simply an inhuman and ruthless object, actively trying to destroy the life of the turtle. I think the passage about the turtle is preparing the reader for the chapters to come. Steinbeck is presenting the dichotomy between the bank and the farmers through this passage with the cars.

In Chapter five, it says ¨A bank isn´t like a man. Or an owner with fifty thousand acres, he isn´t like a man either. That´s the monster (p.45.)¨ The woman represents mankind. Humans watch out for each other; they share food and they give each other a hand, they don´t kill. Whereas, trucks and banks are monsters, heartless machines that work for profit, intentionally swerving to destroy the lives of the determined and slow moving Okie.

Capitalism and the Land

A theme that really resonates in the book for me is the relationship between men and women and the land. This relationship is revealed perhaps most clearly and interestingly in chapter 5, one of Steinbeck’s “interchapters”.

What resounds most in this chapter is the sentiment of estrangement from the land felt by the imagery and the story presented in this chapter. Steinbeck depicts a man whose job it is to operate a tractor and plow the land that was formerly worked by the hands of the previous small farming tenants. The tractor as a machine acts as a barrier between the man and the land that is alienating and devoid of human emotion. Steinbeck underscores the inhumanity of the man by describing him: “The man sitting in the iron seat did not look like a man: gloved, goggled, rubber dust mask over nose and mouth, he was part of the monster, a robot in the seat.” The “monster” in this passage is a reference to the tractor he is operating. Steinbeck goes on to describe the estrangement of man to the land he is working: “his feet did not stamp the clods or feel the warmth and power of the earth.” The chapter uses interesting metaphors of surgery and rape to describe the contact between the machine and the land in contrast to the hands of men. By making the comparison between performing surgery and farming, the reader gets a clinical and sterile association to the operation, not one of “warmth and power.” Perhaps more illuminating is the comparison between this form of mechanized farming and rape. Seeding the ground is no longer an expression of love or comparable to an act of consensual intercourse, however, it is described violently, without human emotion, unnatural: “Twelve curved iron penes, erected in the foundry, orgasms set by gears, raping methodically, raping without passion.” The chapter creates a contrast between this detachment and exploitation of the land and the former tenant who is defending his home and right to stay on the land. When pleading the man to spare his home, he proudly says, “I built it with my hands…It’s mine. I built it.” There is a sense of pride and ownership attached to his property that was born out of direct contact of his hands that is absent in the work of the man and the tractor.

Throughout this chapter Steinbeck effectively gives the reader an impression of the inhumanity of this sort of capitalistic manner of treating farmland and the immorality of the transference of small farmers to the takeover of corporate farmers and banks. Steinbeck reveals the barriers created by these forces and institutions between men and the land they exploit, depriving them of pride and ownership.

Sunday, September 13, 2009

Images of Nature in Janie's Life

Through out the novel, there are several references to nature being involved with Janie's life. The beginning of her life as an adult begins with her under a pear tree, trying to come to terms with the cycle of all things natural. When Nanna sees Janie kissing the boy, I expected a lecture on purity and chastity, not about needing a good marriage in order to be taken care of.

The purest thing in Janie's life always seems to be nature. She returns to nature in times of strife and in times of happiness. As a reader, I expected her life to be full of working on the land and living from it, not trying to marry and escape from it. When Janie was with her first husband she was so repulsed by the idea of a woman working, and especially with a woman working the land. I was very surprised by this. Perhaps this reaction was due to her grandmother having been a slave and thus Janie formed an opinion of work being always akin to slavery. This idea is shown yet again when she marries Joe and is forced to work miserably in the store.

Another theme tied into nature through out this novel is change. Every time Janie has a life change, she is outside. First again with the pear tree, then when she meets Joe outside on the road and agrees to marry him, next when she meets Tea Cake and spends time on the porch or fishing and doing other outdoor activities. The most important example of this is the hurricane. This is the only scene where nature is a negative force in Janie's life, and comes at the happiest point in her life, creating an interesting juxtaposition.

The Hurricane: Nature as a Leveler

The hurricane at first seems contradictory to the way nature is originally depicted in Their Eyes Were Watching God. Throughout the text, natural elements appear in forms that are rejuvenating or enriching to Janie's life in various ways. The blossoming pear tree is associated with Janie's blooming sexuality, and the muck seems to represent Janie's freedom from many social barriers that existed in Eatonville.
It is impossible, though, to view nature as a purely positive element in Janie's life. The hurricane undermines this simplistic reading most obviously. Its destructive force brings ruin to the happiness that she has forged with Tea Cake. Instead, the natural world (as opposed to towns/civilization) acts as a levelling force in this novel. As we discussed in class, the muck covers the people who work there, and in many ways it seems to erase skin color.
Mrs. Turner acts as a foil to the muck. She runs an eatery, one of the few places of business mentioned in this section of the story. This business, and Mrs. Turner herself, are obviously out of place in this environment. The muck, which creates equality, is juxtaposed to Mrs. Turner who wants to "class off."
The hurricane also works in a similar way. Men, women, and even animals make a singular movement to higher ground. Tea Cake even comments that some of the dead have been so mangled by the storm that it is impossible to know their race. At the same time, the white men of an established town insist on the importance of color. These men appear ridiculous against the Armageddon-like backdrop that Hurston has created.
Throughout the novel, Hurston sets up a binary between civilization and nature, portraying both the positive and negative aspects of each. Finally, however, she reveals, through this opposition, the absurdity of many social structures.

Race & Gender as Social Constructions

As we discussed in class, There Eyes Were Watching God positions race as a continuum where things aren’t so cut and dry. Mrs. Turner is black, but doesn’t like black people; Dr. Simmons is white, but he wants to help Tea Cake and Janie; Janie is black, but her fellow black community members in Eatonville see her as “above them.” The color of the characters’ skin doesn’t necessarily indicate their position within society, and instead, their social position has a more profound affect on their racial self-identity. When Tea Cake is looking through dead bodies after the hurricane, he said, “Shucks! Nobody can’t tell nothin’ ‘bout some uh dese bodies, de shape dey’s in. Can’t tell whether dey’s white or black,” (171), and that point is an interesting one: race isn’t so much the color of the skin and “blackness” or “whiteness” is variable.
This same continuum is also seen in gender/sexuality within the novel. What it means to be a woman or what it means to be a man is tested and redefined throughout a novel. When Janie undermines Jody (which, in my opinion is a feminine name, although a nickname), and says, “But Ah’m uh woman every inch of me, and Ah know it. Dat’s uh whole lot more’n you kin say…When you pull down yo’ britches, you look lak de change uh life,” Janie emasculates Jody and that leads to his ultimate demise. The upset in the balance of male/female power within their relationship makes Jody less of a man, both in his mind and within the community. Janie, also, is a very different kind of woman – free, independent and self-satisfying by the end of the novel. And as we discussed in class, she has a lifelong struggle with work – not wanting to be a “mule;” disliking the store; and finally finding herself in the muck and enjoying work – but the one job she doesn’t explore is motherhood – arguably the most important job/purpose of a woman. But by her not being a mother, she challenges what it means to be a woman, and her gender comes from her sexuality, not her role within sexual reproduction.
- ANS

Janie's laborious life?

In the days following the celebration of labor in our country, I would like to examine how the idea of work is portrayed in Hurston’s novel, “Their Eyes Were Watching God.”

The idea of work helps to set an immediate generational and philosophical contrast between the young Janie and her grandmother, Nanny, a former slave who has suffered a life of forced labor. The reader can observe a big difference in the way these two characters view life and labor. Logan Killicks, an older man, is painted as a stable suitor for Janie in the eyes of Nanny because of his abundance of land, a reference to, not only the possibility of labor, but, the possibility of prospering from it, an attractive prospect to a former slave. Janie could not show less interest in working, however. She is repulsed by the signs of hard labor in Logan’s body: “his toe-nails look lak mule foots ‘tain’t nothin’ in de way of him washin’ his feet every evenin’ before he comes tuh bed” and “He don’t even never mention nothin’ pretty.” At the request of Logan for Janie to help him on the farm, Janie refuses and shortly after leaves him for a man that promises her a less laborious life: “You behind a plow! You ain’t got no mo’ business wid uh plow than uh hog is got wid auh holiday!”

As the reader later discovers, Janie’s life with Joe Starks is not what he promises which brings us to another stage of Janie’s character development in regards to labor. In the contrast between Janie’s marriages to Joe and Tea Cake there appears a divergence between the idea of leisure and work. Janie detests her job as a storekeeper, a duty assigned to her under her oppressive marriage with Joe, and the idea of labor quickly becomes equated with unhappiness, while the leisure spent with Tea Cake (fishing, gambling, picnics, playing checkers, vacations…etc.) becomes associated with her happiness. “Somebody wanted her to play. Somebody thought it natural for her to play.”

The idea of work as an oppressive task is underscored by the incident of the mule in the novel. In a great symbolic gesture, Joe buys an overworked mule from his oppressive “slave-driver” in order to free him from his life of labor and struggle. Its interesting to consider these notions of freedom and work as similar to slavery in the context of a post-slavery era of our country.

However, finally we see Janie working in perhaps the least glamorous area of work that she is presented with in the novel. Janie joins Tea Cake “in the muck”, with Tea Cake with the most satisfaction that she experiences throughout the novel. She finds the perfect balance between leisure and wor spending her days working alongside Tea Cake and her evenings with her friends dancing and gambling and talking. This evolution in the way Janie experiences her work life reflects her evolution and growth as a character in her search for love and happiness. Not only does it achieve this but it provides a sort of resolution to the perception of labor as oppressive as established under slavery.