Sunday, October 18, 2009

Doubled Structure

The section describing the Ricketts' fireplace is about aesthetics. Agee gives the motivation for posting so many "attractive pieces of paper" on the wall by the fireplace as the fact that the Ricketts are "more actively fod of pretty things that the other families are." Agee substantiates his claim that the aesthetics of this house are as important as the rest by giving this section so much weight. While the Grudger house receives 60 pages of the book, Agee condenses the Rickett house to only eight pages. Even though the fireplace section is short, it occupies a full quarter of the description of the Rickett's house.

Agee structures this section similarly to his whole book. He begins with the images: describing in detail all the advertisements, magazine covers, and calendars which adorn the wall. Then he moves to words: the ad copy and captions and names of months. Like presenting the Walker photos first without caption and then the text of the book, Agee has divorced the media. This doubled, microcosmic structure highlights the re-presentational act of aesthetics in general, and Agee's own writing in particular.

Agee is always very concerned about the validity of his enterprise of writing about the tenant farmers, and in particular the danger of his reader aestheticizing Let Us Now Praise Famous Men. On first reading, I suspected Agee of using the doubled structure to comment on his own failure to present an unaestheticized version of the tenant family's condition.

However, in the next section of the book, "Notes," he gives us a treatise on 'Beauty' which celebrates which does not go along with the self-deprecation tack I've begun to expect from Agee. In this section, he insists that we not ignore the beauty of the houses. He even says that this aesthetic is "at least as important a part of the fact as the [economic and human] abomination itself." But then he goes further, saying that this "unintentional" work is no less aesthetic than an intentional work art (implying 'such as this book itself') because in reality the intentional work is not really very intentional. Here he again links his own artistic act with that of the houses, and does not demonize it, but rather argues for its necessity.



Family Rank and Hope

Agee is very careful in Let Us Now Praise Famous Men to describe each tenant family in detail, so they do not merge into one generalization of the tenant farmer life. Before Agee goes into deep explanation of the families' homes, he describes their monetary situation in relation to one another.

The families are essentially ranked by Agee according to how much money they have in profit at the end of the year. The Woods family cleared at best $1300 one year, the Gudgers cleared $125, and the Ricketts have consistently remained in debt. Agee spends a lot of time describing in particular the Ricketts fireplace, and describing carefully the difference between their home and the average tenant farmer.

In his description of the Rickett home, he explains that their home was once inhabited by a small farmer, not a tenant, who likely lost his home in foreclosure from the same people who the Ricketts now work for. The Rickett family is in the worst of conditions financially, and lives in a home whose history could be foreshadowing of their future.

The fireplace is of utmost importance to the Ricketts, since it is the one object that can make a room seem “more or less well-appointed than it actually is” (183). About the Ricketts fireplace are objects which serve no functional purpose, but which provide only aesthetic pleasure. The posters hanging above the mantle-piece are of higher-class people, such as men in suits, and objects which they cannot afford, like roasts and cakes. Compared to the other fireplaces in the Grudge and Woods homes, the Ricketts fireplace is just decoration. The Grudge and Woods family use the fireplace to hold objects like nail files and hair combs. The other fireplaces do still have some relics of attempts to make their homes “pretty”, though their neglect is now apparent. Mrs. Grudge, for example, once attempted to decorate her mantle with lace, but admits to have given up trying to make the house pretty. The Ricketts still maintain some hope in their home, and still attempt to make it more livable for that reason. It is ironic in the sense that they are the family that will most likely not make it much longer without facing foreclosure; it seems as though the only thing they have left is hope.

the fireplace: an homage or a burial shrine?

When asked to examine the lengthy description of the Ricketts' fireplace one experiences a sensory overload consistent with the construction of the rest of the novel. This could, like the rest of these kind of instances, be serving to throw the reader off., but I think, in this particular case, Agee is giving us this description to emphasize another point. I noticed that almost every item mentioned are, or involve, photographs of other people doing exciting things, or living better lives. I think the pictures of attractive and delicious foodstuffs are most telling because that connects on a very primal level of necessity and does the most to highlight their deficiencies. The photos are of attractive people, which the Ricketts', plagued by mediocre hygiene and lives of toil, are decidedly not. The people are consuming high end products like Coca Cola and using Lysol disinfectant, which the Ricketts' certainly can not afford.

It is clear that the Ricketts' chose to surround the focal point of their house with images of a life that they will never be able to live, the question now is "why?" There are two options which I believe can explain this phenomena. The first possibility is that they are simply paying homage to that sort of lifestyle and have come to terms with their station in a lower class. This kind of behavior is consistent with people worshipping celebrity not because they are jealous of their success or wish in any way to gain their exact position, but simply because the glamour makes them feel better by proxy. This is the healthiest explanation, because it would suggest a makeshift comfort, which is something that Agee tries to highlight, I feel.

That is, however, not the option which seems most correct here. Upon reading the description and then flipping back to actually look at the picture of said fireplace, it did not most closely resemble a middle school girl's room plastered with celebrity photos, as the description suggests, but instead a burial shrine saturated with the images and symbols of something that is dead. It seems like a dumping ground for the ambition of the young during the transition to the apathy of the old. These pictures are reminders of things that they will never have, they may look on them nostalgically, like one does when looking at a picture of a dead relative, but never hopeful for the resurrection of that person.

Pretty Things on purpose or Beauty by accident

I thought I detected a derisive attitude toward the Ricketts that was absent in the descriptions of the Gudger and Woods houses. Agee's comments in narration, "there is no soap because it is foolish to waste money that can be eaten with on soap when any fool knows there is nothing cleaner than water" and "beyond their faces and hands the people, and their clothing and bedding, and their pans and dishes, and their house, are generally by standards other than their own insanely or completely dirty, or almost beyond possibility of being dirtier, short of a deliberated or cult-like acquisition of dirtiness" - seem sarcastic and condescending, as does his emphasis on the misspelled crayon-on-cardboard sign that reads "Pleas! be quite" (172-3). While there are certainly pathetic moments in his portrayals of the other two houses, those are presented as outside the control of those families. But here, Agee seems to make a point of showing the failures of the Ricketts themselves.

So when I read the section about their fireplace, my first impression was that he was being patronizing by using the childish term "pretty things." Several other people have already pointed out that many of the "pretty things" above the fireplace are advertisements for items like whiskey or fancy clothing that the family would not be able to afford.

The next section in the book compares unintended "chance" beauty with intended beauty or art (178). Here and elsewhere, Agee comes down in favor of unintended beauty (like the way the light strikes the vase in the unused room at the Gudger house). If I am not projecting ideas onto the text and Agee really is critical of the Ricketts, then perhaps it is because he disagrees with their hopeless desires for manufactured, traditional ideas of "pretty things" when the other families have done better with their accidental beauty.

Nostalgia and the Ricketts

I’d like to play with a point Kaelin about the pictures at the Ricketts: “Pictures of people participating in activities that the Ricketts cannot personally identify with were, perhaps, hung in unrequited desire.” I think the pictures extend further in meaning than that. The pictures are reminders, and they are quite possibly there in unrequited desire; however, I think they serve more as nostalgic reminders than anything else. As Agee iterates, the Ricketts, with their nine children and ten dollar a day wages, live in a deplorable state (103). Yet, years before, when the Ricketts parents were relatively healthy and the children fewer in number, the Ricketts were “almost prosperous” (104).  They owned ten cows, they lived near a stream, and they owned mules. A string of unfortunate occurrences landed them in their current state. Everything about this state is a nostalgic reminder of past splendor.

I mean, if you look at their house as a whole, it is not the house of a tenant or sharecropper, it is a house that once belonged to a small farmer, a land owner. The fireplace also used to be splendid,  “broad and high, and handsome in its Greek panelings” (174). Everything is a reminder of something that was once nice, and is now falling apart. So, as a distraction, the Ricketts paste pretty reminders on their walls, pictures of “Coca-Cola girls” and “great rosy blue-eyed babies sucking their thumbs.” The pictures remind them that they were once nice, that they are now falling apart. But there was a time when they could afford some of the things in the pictures, and I’m sure those times are vivid memories, tasting like yesterday on their tongues. The Woods and the Gudgers were never in a situation where they had any of the things the Ricketts once had, so they can hardly miss them. But the Ricketts, unless they find some sort of prosperity once again, will always remain active admirers (174). 

-Jessica Grabert

Saturday, October 17, 2009

The Rickett's fireplace: Beauty is in the eye of the beholder

One can be forever lost in the deep descriptions of Agee's Let Us Now Praise Famous Men; however, my interpretation of this particular passage is rather simple. His analyses of the Woods and Gudgers houses are much more focused on the lack of much beyond the necessities. He depicts the Gudgers house as very minimal, with little to no decorations of any sort, and the furniture is nothing more than practical. His description of their fireplace paints a very plain picture. "All the frame and mantel of the fireplace and the rather dark, blank wall, to a squared-off height of perhaps five and a half feet, and some of the wall beyond the frame, are whitewashed...yet a very cold and fine white, the edges of the work carefully labored and inexpert," (Agee, 151).

The Woods' home is told to have been minimal as well, though a little more decorated than the Gudgers. In their short passage, they are described as having decorations such as an ancestor's sword and scabbard on the wall of one of the bedrooms, a mirror, and smaller knick-knacks, but nothing seemingly very inspired or personal.

What sets the Ricketts apart, I think, is as Kaelin pointed 0ut; there is more personal connection implied with the items listed. A little earlier in the passage, Agee points out that the room with the fireplace is "of no use for living" becaues of its caved-in chimmney (Agee, 172-173), which is interested to find out later that this is the room he describes as being filled with their "pretty things". He lists a number of magazine covers and advertisements the family has set aside, indicating their interest in each of the images. The family is noted for its stinginess, but the family appears to make-do with what they have, and thus the never-ending list of favored images they set aside. As Agee mentions in his notes following the passage, he believes houses such as the aforementioned households "achieve an extraordinary 'beauty'," (Agee, 177) in that the esthetics are normally overlooked by the obvious shortcomings at hand, when in turn, despite the family's short income, a house such as the Ricketts' still sports an eye for what it deems as its own "beauty".

Friday, October 16, 2009

Blog 4

I for one am trying to understand the endlessly detailed descriptions of the houses of all the families in any way I can. Whether Agee is going between formal and perosnal writing is irrelevant at this point as everything is subject to interpretation. The mood is mythical for whatever part of the book a person is on and can be dissected and analized based on the way Agee wanted the book to be read (which itself is a topic of discussion). The Ricketts' fireplace is open to all ideas of sliding difficulty. It could simply be a collection of random papers picked up by a watchful eye or go so deep into each family member's personsal asperatinos and obviously crushed dreams for different circumstances. The wall contains almost every conceivable image for fantasy and desire while also containing cultural norms (the adds for food, drink, stores, clothes, and others) and several relating to history or religion (the many Christmas Dinners and "incidents in the life of Jesus") thus making it a type of treasure chest shared by the family and grown over time to help them relax when small times like that occur.

But this all again related to what Agee wants reader to see from his eyes. He sets up the scene to his standards of metaphor but leaves us to come up with our own having mentioned at the start that he wishes nothing to be pointed at him. Read it and leave but in that brief message is another and another leading to infinite possiblities which (I say this word strongly) may be Agee's goal, fulfilling his desire for something I will not try to understand. And by doing this, he draws everyone who reads it in whether they like it or not (the book, not him).