Sunday, September 20, 2009

Death Ritual in The Grapes of Wrath

In Chapter 13 of The Grapes of Wrath, Grampa dies and the Joad family spends a considerable amount of time discussing the burial procedures.  Although they worry that Grampa won’t be buried in a way that is honorable, they eventually decide to bury him themselves. I began to consider the extravagant burial rituals that take place throughout the world today for the loved ones of the living. Often, the lavishness of a funeral and/or burial does not even represent the value of the deceased, but rather, they are status symbols that demonstrate the wealth of the deceased’s family.   

I thought that the method of burial for Grampa was perfect and truly reflected the family’s care for him, while taking into consideration their future needs.  It would have been foolish to spend the forty dollars on a proper burial when the family knew that they would never make it to California without that money.  It is amazing how in today’s society, families feel the need to spend abundant amounts of money and resources to commemorate the dead, when those resources could be much better suited towards future generations.  I have heard it said that one of the most selfish things a person can wish for upon his or her death is to take up a permanent space on the earth.  I can’t say I disagree with this.  At some point, the earth will run out of space for graveyards and cemeteries, and even then, they won’t last forever.            

I think that, even though they may not have realized it, the Joad’s reflected upon the life of Grampa in a way that was honorable but unselfish.  While they made sure that his body wouldn’t be found right away, they knew that it was an eventual possibility.  They identified him and buried him with Scripture, which represents a value of the family, and then moved on with their life.  They didn’t waste time reflecting on what could not be changed.  I think contemporary culture could learn a lesson from the Joad’s and their temporal attitude towards death.  

The Sin of Disconnection

As the Joad’s journey onward to the west, in Steinbeck’s novel The Grapes of Wrath, characters, religions, and varying moral compasses seem to come into brief focus, are given a quick examination, and pass on as the story continues- like an object being viewed from a passing car. In such a way the readers are shown several different thoughts on what constitutes a sin or an immoral practice, but in the end, it seems that Steinbeck pushes the reader to believe that the only real sin in this novel is the “sin” of disconnection. The characters and institutions that Steinbeck portrays negatively are those that have lost touch with men and the reality of the situation. Inversely, the saviors or heroes of the novel all seem to be extremely grounded in the times and the people and situations around them.

Take for instance, the ex-preacher, Jim Casy. Previously Casy had sermonized on salvation and the dangers of sin, but when times change so to does Casy. He begins to modify his thoughts on what is holy and what constitutes a sin and after his metamorphosis he comes to a very realistic and practical definition for both terms. With these new definitions for religion, Casy proceeds to spread his wisdom bringing, if not necessarily joy or happiness, contentment or a sense of ease to those around him. With his words he eases the suffering of those around him, leaving it up to them to decide what burdens or sins they choose to carry so as to not increase the hardships his companions are forced to face. Such as his treatment of Uncle John, when he asks Casy what constitutes a sin, the preacher tells him a sin is only a sin if he believes it to be one- leaving it up to John to decide if he would bear that burden or not. As a contrast, the reader is introduced to Lisbeth Sandry who follows a harsh and demanding religion that is extremely disconnected from the times around her. Her preaching and accusations of sin only increase the suffering of those around her. Lisabeth is extremely disconnected from those around her, as she attends an off-camp church that denounces and demonizes her fellow campers. By portraying this very religious character in such a disconnected and tragic way, Steinbeck is able to reinforce the importance of religion being connected to the people and situation.

Another example of this disconnection as an immoral trait comes from Steinbeck’s condemnation of the banks, the rich men, and their tractors. These institutions and forces in the story are some of the worst or most demonized in Steinbeck’s work. Steinbeck continually reminds the readers how the rich men and their tractors are no longer connected to the land and the farming process, similar to how banks seem to be disconnected from the men who are supposed to control them. As the most heartless forces the reader encounters in this book, the one common and most striking trait they all carry is that of being disconnected.

This theme of disconnection as sin overrides and weaves its way through most of the characters, institutions, and religions in Steinbeck’s novel. The thrust of this idea points to the importance of unity and community between men during trying times such as the ones presented in the novel. It seems that Steinbeck wants the reader to realize that community is what brings men through hard times, it is this unity that allows them to prevail- but it is a unity that is only possible when the main point on character’s moral compass points to connection and as a result portrays disconnection as one of the cardinal sins.

Anonymity in the novel

Through out the novel, there are several characters that seem to have little importance. They appear sporadically and disappear from the story forever, many times not even leaving a name. They give snapshots of humanity at the time through their minor interactions with main characters.

Steinbeck traveled with a famous photographer all across the dust bowl, taking pictures and learning about the state of people's lives. While he did back down on his offer to write a book with the photographer, I think these small snippets of humanity we get with these faceless, nameless characters are a just like a photograph. In a photograph, you may see a man behind the counter in a store. You can infer how much money he has, how happy, and what he does for a living; but that is all you have, just inferences.

The novel first opens with a truck driver. We learn so much about him, his life, and his life goals, but never learn his name. Again, just like a photograph. Next we have the used car salesman. We learn livelihood and a little about him, but no name. The same pattern is repeated again and again. The question is, does it matter that we never learn their name? We still get a different perspective on life in the dust bowl. In the chapter with the turtle, we never learn the names of the different drivers that nearly end the turtle's life. The impact they potentially could have on the life of this animal is huge, and we never even learn about them.

I believe the theme of anonymity reflects the impact these farmers and migrants had on the country and how they are hardly remembered or realized. They become part of the earth of our country and it's history, then quietly fade into the past, just like a photo.

Organized Chaos

Throughout Grapes of Wrath, there is an interesting focus on familiar and social organization. In Chapter 17, Steinbeck describes, in detail, the social organization that emerges amongst the families moving west. Uprooted from their former lives and communities, the immigrants find a new social norm amongst their fellow travelers and each evening “a new unit was formed”(197). “In the long hot light, they were silent in the cars moving slowly westward; but at night they integrated with any group they found. Thus they changed their social life—changed as in the whole universe only man can change. They were not farm men any more, bit migrant men”(196). The families discovered new social rules, rights, laws, conduct government, and they created these mini-communities every night, and then dismantled them in the morning. The process seems it would be exhausting for the characters, but perhaps this is a way to create order and classification within a life situation that is rife with upheaval, movement and uncertainty. Or, this means of social organization is a natural progression from the importance placed on hierarchy within the family. Steinbeck puts a lot of emphasis on each family member’s “role”, and the characters, so far, don’t seem to push those boundaries. Each character knows their place, and the Joads organize themselves very naturally, automatically, and without much discussion: “And without any signal, the family gathered by the truck, and the congress, the family government went into session”(99). Before they leave for their trip they convene to discuss their journey, and in a very literal moment, the family place themselves physically to mirror their position within the family hierarchy. Pa, Uncle John and Grampa form “the nucleus;” Tom, Connie, and Noah form around them; the women stand behind them with their hands on their hips; and the children quietly play around in the background. This set family structure is a apparent and set – but whether it will uphold or shift during the journey to California is yet to be determined.
- ANS

Interchapter Style: Description and Discourse

While all the interchapters of Grapes of Wrath share the generalized and musing tone which lifts them out of the Joad narrative, most can be further categorized as "description" or "discourse" chapters.

About half of the interchapters (specifically 1,3,11,14,21,25,29) are description chapters. They employ general terms such as "the land, the migrants, the women." Some are just portraits of some piece of the landscape--a vacant house, a migrant turtle. Others give an outline of actions people take, but without specifics.

The other interchapters (5,7,9,12,15,23,27) are what I term "discourse" chapters because they are dominated by speech related to us in the form of indirect discourse. The narrator temporarily shifts without warning into the voice of some person. Quotation marks are almost never used, and for good reason. Even though these chapters give a sense of the presence of personalities, only a few are actually about specific characters. We get names occasionally, for example in chapter 15 with Mae and Al's diner, and in chapter 7 the boss car salesman refers to a co-worker named Joe. But overall, these interchapters could still be about any migrant, any car salesman, any diner. The reader is still supposed to generalize from these vignettes, even if the language is not explicitly so general as "the men squatted on their hams."

Chapters 17 and 19 are hybrids. They begin with a description and shift to discourse halfway through. The shift is a good place to see the contrast between the two modes. In Chapter 17 it occurs with a long dash on page 196 of the Penguin edition. Everything before the dash talks about "the families" and "the migrant people." After the dash, however, most of the rest of the chapter is discourse (in dialect) without attribution to a speaker. At the very end, description comes back with the sentence: "The families ate quickly, and the dishes were dipped and wiped." In Chapter 19, the shift occurs on page 234. The narrator has already changed from talking about collective nouns such as "Okies" and "Californians" to a specific "homeless, hungry man." But the shift in style comes in the following paragraph: "He drove his old car into a town. He scoured the farms for work. Where can we sleep tonight?"

Throughout the novel, interchapters alternate with Joad chapters with two exceptions: chapters 11 and 12 as well as chapters 14 and 15 are pairs of back-to-back interchapters. The reason Steinbeck can pull off the pairs and not seem to disturb the oscillatory rhythm of his narrative is precisely that he has paired a description and a discourse chapter together. Chapter 11 is a short description of the dialpidated house. Chapter 12 gives a vignette of a migrant family trying to buy a used tire. While chapter 12 contains some description (including the famous passage about Route 66), it is dominated by speech. Likewise, chapter 14 is the description of how the collective "we" is a result, not a cause. Chapter 15, however, is the most narrative of all the interchapters--the scene in Mae and Al's diner. It contains much dialogue, and even quotation marks (though they only begin several pages into the chapter).

The two types of interchapters give another, lower frequency, oscillation to the narrative structure of The Grapes of Wrath which is superimposed on the first sinusoidal pattern we identified in class as well as the linear trend of the Joad quest journey.

Community spirit

Community plays a large role in Steinbeck’s, “The grapes of Wrath.” Originally the Joad family was apart of a tightly knit community where families have spent generations on one plot of land. The Joad family wasn’t ready to remove their roots, but they were not willing to stay and become as obsessed like Muley who can’t seem to let go.
Even before the Joad family sets off for California they allow Casy to go with them, showing how the family already recognizes that it isn’t just blood that matters to a group of people. Through out the endless miles the Joad family crossed, the Joad’s remained courteous and nice, never accepting charity or hand-outs, refusing to be seen as bums. This can be seen at various points, such as the fake Shell gas station. The Joad’s made sure to pay for their supplies. Another example is when Tom is speaking with the one eyed man. While he was harsh with the man Tom still encouraged the man to move, to try and get to a better station in life.
Then there is the Wilsons, fellow travelers of the road. Both the Joad’s and the Wilson’s were in the same situation, in desperate need of help. Without the two families help, neither family would have gotten far, as the Joad’s car could have very well broken down in the mountains or how much care the Wilson’s gave to the Joad’s by allowing Granpa Joad to be buried in the Wilson’s tent. Before the families have the unfortunate misfortune to split paths the two families seem as one.
If there is one moment to summarize the families view on community, it can be seen when Casy and Tom first meet. Casy is speaking of the time he spent in the wilderness when he says, “Maybe all men got one big soul ever’body’s a part of.” This simple statement shows how the government camp functioned without any trouble, or why the Joad family always lends a helping hand to any one in need. By the time the journey is over, no longer is the family concerned about themselves, but for everyone.

Blog 2

Even though it is obvious of Steinbeck's bias or at least implied bias of people in The Grapes of Wrath, I still don't see why he only alludes to the highest and most powerful people or organizations as something straight out of myth. This has left me with a bad taste in my mouth since all that is left for him to grossly over ridicule is the smaller and local groups such as the car salesmen, the banks, and the police and townspeople the Joads encounter as they head to California. It is easy to vilify them when they are seen in a solely archetypal structure. But however simple it was to see these traits when Steinbeck was traveling with Horace Bristol, I find it insulting to both groups in that the migrant workers could only be pitiful and the local populations could only be cruel and judgemental (with one exception in the truck stop scene so far). My question is whether or not Steinbeck did this on purpose to further any statement or goal he was trying to reach with the book. In sacrificing dignity and humanity of certain groups, could a real change or even a hard look at their circumstances be done in order to improve anything? However, when looking at the group most likely to read the novel thoughtfully (the upper class and intellectual do-gooders of the time) wouldn't it simply be seen as an attack on their own position (as many called him a communist and the book "red propaganda") and thus be left as a piece of writing and a call to arms in a shock value kind of way? What I see is Steinbeck either writing this his own way for more heartwarming and retching story or doing it to inflame public opinion and glorify his work and ability (attention for attention's sake).